Advertisement
There’s no higher honour in Northern Hemisphere rugby than pulling on the red jersey of the British & Irish Lions. However, for every Test-capped legend, there’s a host of greats that through timing, injury, or selection quirks never got that elusive Test cap.
This excluded Lions XV features nine England players, three Scots, two Irish and one Welsh, with more than 1,350 international caps and an abundance of Six Nations titles between them.
15. Chris Paterson (Scotland)
Mr. Consistent. With 109 caps for Scotland, Paterson was a metronomic kicker and fearless full-back, who often shone even when Scotland didn’t. He never got close to a Lions Test jersey, which feels scandalous given his reliability.
14. Mike Brown (England)
Combative, fiery, and utterly uncompromising, Brown was England’s heartbeat during the Stuart Lancaster years. Many feel his relentless drive and defensive steel would’ve fitted perfectly in a Lions jersey.
13. Henry Slade (England)
Slade oozes class. His blend of creativity, pace, and defensive awareness has made him a staple in the England midfield, yet the Lions selectors have always looked elsewhere. At 32, it may now be too late—but he has every right to feel hard done by.
12. Mike Tindall (England)
A World Cup winner with 75 England caps, Tindall was the beating heart of England’s midfield for a decade. Solid, smart, and effective, his omission from Lions Test history is one of the great curiosities.
11. Jonny May (England)
The second-highest try scorer in England’s history. His electric pace and aerial prowess made him a nightmare for defences. Yet in both 2017 and 2021, he was overlooked when it mattered most with the Lions deemed the pinacle of a players career.
10. George Ford (England)
Few fly-halves in the past decade have marshalled a game like Ford. Whether pulling strings behind the pack or stepping into pressure kicks, Ford has shown repeatedly he belongs at the elite level. A crying shame that the humble playmaker never toured.
9. Peter Stringer (Ireland)
Tiny in stature, massive in heart. With 98 Irish caps and countless key moments—his flick pass in the 2006 Grand Slam decider, for one—Stringer remains one of Ireland’s great generals. But the Lions never handed him a Test chance.
1. Cian Healy (Ireland)
A 137-cap Ireland legend and multiple-time Six Nations champion. Healy’s absence from Lions Test history is purely circumstantial. He toured in 2013 but was injured before the Tests. He would have thrived in red.
2. Dylan Hartley (England)
One of England’s most capped captains, Hartley was a cornerstone of Eddie Jones’ early reign. But a suspension ruled him out of the 2013 tour and injury nixed any 2017 dreams. On form and leadership alone, he deserved his shot.
3. Zander Fagerson (Scotland)
Still in his prime, Fagerson toured in 2021 and has been Scotland’s standout scrummager for years. Despite performing well in the warm-ups, he didn’t get the nod when the Test matches rolled around and missed this year’s tour through injury.
4. Joe Launchbury (England)
One of the most respected locks of his generation. Injuries came at the worst time for Launchbury, denying him a 2017 Lions spot when he was arguably at his peak. A true engine room warrior who would be a welcome addition to any pack.
5. Jonny Gray (Scotland)
A tackling machine and lineout technician. With over 80 Scotland caps and an elite rugby IQ, Gray has consistently delivered. Like many Scots before 2021, Lions recognition was too limited for the former Exeter Chief.
6. Chris Robshaw (England)
Often England’s scapegoat, particulary during the disastrous 2015 World Cup, Robshaw was in fact one of their most reliable flankers. A tireless workhorse with immense leadership qualities, he would’ve brought grit and commitment to any Lions Test side.
7. Josh Navidi (Wales)
Understated but vital. Navidi’s versatility and breakdown brilliance saw him rise to prominence late—but his 2021 tour involvement didn’t translate into a Test debut. A player coaches trust, and opponents fear.
8. Billy Vunipola (England)
The most controversial omission of the 2021 Lions series. At his best, Vunipola is unplayable—dominant in contact and deft with ball in hand. Gatland went another way with Jack Conan, but history may say he left the better No.8 at home.